Though
the Click Five were initially pitched as a marriage between modern chart pop and the classic power pop sound of
Badfinger or
the Raspberries, they ended up (despite the songwriting involvement of
Fountains of Wayne's
Adam Schlesinger) coming across as fakey and processed as a quintet of
Ashlee Simpsons with guitars and matching suits. At first glance, the Brooklyn quartet
Locksley raises similar alarms, down to the unfortunate fondness for identical outfits in their promo photos, but in their case, their fondness for
the Kinks,
Beatles, and pre-
Tommy Who comes across in their spirited indie rock updating of the classic British Invasion sound. The four members of
Locksley went to high school together in Madison, WI. After graduation, lead guitarist
Kai Kennedy, rhythm guitarist
Jesse Laz, bassist
Aaron Collins, and drummer
Sam Bair (in the grand old traditions of band democracy and multi-part harmonies, all four members sing) moved from Wisconsin to the more artistically friendly climes of Brooklyn and began work on their debut album. The band self-released
Safely from the City in the summer of 2004. The follow-up EP,
Locksley, was released in 2005 on the Light Brigade label, featuring the single and video "Don't Make Me Wait," which helped gain the group an opening slot on
OK Go's national tour. In the summer of 2006, a new single, "Why Can't I Be You?" (not the 1987
Cure hit of the same title), received wider exposure when its video won the polling on an episode of The Freshmen, a battle-of-the-bands show on Viacom's college-oriented digital cable channel mtvU, making
Locksley the first unsigned band to win that honor. After landing one of their songs in the blockbuster movie Cloverfield and supporting
Hanson on their 2007 tour, the band released a new version of
Don't Make Me Wait in 2008. That same year the MTV cable network began using the band's "Why Can't I Be You?" as the theme for a reality series of the same name. The network also hired the band to headline their cross-country Choose or Lose Tour. By this time
Collins had been replaced in the lineup by
Jesse's brother,
Jordan Laz. ~ Stewart Mason, All Music Guide