Growing out of the American underground of the late '80s,
Liz Phair fused lo-fi indie rock production techniques and styles with the sensibility and structure of classic singer/songwriters.
Exile in Guyville,
Phair's debut album, was enthusiastically praised upon its 1993 release and spawned a rash of imitators, particularly American female singer/songwriters, over the following years. For her part,
Phair wasn't able to break into the mainstream, even with the support of the press and MTV.
Whip-Smart, her second album, was heavily promoted upon its 1994 release, yet despite its relatively strong chart positions, it was viewed as a disappointment and
Phair's momentum declined steadily during the mid-'90s, as she took several years to record her third album.
Phair (born April 17, 1967) was born in New Haven, CT, and adopted by wealthy parents, who raised her in the Chicago suburb Winnetka. After high school, she studied art at Oberlin College in Ohio. At Oberlin, she became fascinated with underground indie rock and eventually became friends with guitarist
Chris Brokaw, who later joined
Come. Following their college graduation,
Phair and
Brokaw moved to San Francisco, where she tried to become an artist.
Eventually,
Brokaw moved out east and
Phair moved back to Chicago, where she began writing songs. Soon, she began releasing homemade tapes of these songs under the name
Girlysound. While she supported herself by selling her charcoal drawings on the streets of Wicker Park, she was becoming involved in various portions of the Chicago alternative music scene; in particular, she became friends with
Urge Overkill, a drummer named
Brad Wood, and
John Henderson, the head of the Chicago-based indie label Feel Good All Over.
Henderson and
Phair tried to re-record some of the
Girlysound tapes with
Wood, yet the pair had a falling out during the sessions, leaving
Wood as
Phair's only collaborator.
Brokaw, who had by then joined
Come, was still receiving
Girlysound tapes and he gave a copy to
Gerard Cosley, the head of
Come's record label, Matador. By the summer of 1992, Matador had signed
Phair and she began recording her debut album in earnest.
Adapting its title from an
Urge Overkill song,
Exile in Guyville, her debut album, was released to strong reviews in the summer of 1993. Many articles focused on
Phair's claim that the double album was structured as a response to
the Rolling Stones' classic
Exile on Main St. Over the course of the year, the record slowly built a dedicated following in America, both among critics and alternative rock fans. At the end of the year, it topped many Best of the Year critics polls, including The Village Voice and Spin. With all the attention focused on
Phair, many indie rock figures -- particularly members of the Chicago noise rock scene such as
Steve Albini -- were developing a resentment toward her and launching an attack at the singer and the heavy media attention
Exile in Guyville received. The criticism couldn't halt the progress of
Phair and
Exile, and in early 1994 she launched her first tour, which was plagued by her stage fright. Around the same time, MTV began airing "Never Said" and, as a result of all the hype, the album briefly appeared in the charts in February. By the spring of 1994 it had sold over 200,000 copies -- a remarkable number for an independent release.
By that time,
Phair had begun work on her follow-up record. Matador had signed a distribution deal with Atlantic Records in 1994, and her second album was going to be one of the first to be heavily promoted by the alliance. Indeed,
Whip-Smart was released to a whirlwind of media attention -- including
Phair, dressed only in negligee, on the cover of Rolling Stone -- and debuted at number 27 upon its fall 1994 release. "Supernova," the first single from the album, received heavy airplay on MTV and alternative rock radio, becoming a Top Ten modern rock hit. However,
Whip-Smart received mediocre reviews and never developed into the hit that it was expected to be.
Phair didn't tour to support the album and was slow to deliver a second single. By the time the title track was released as a single in the spring of 1995, the album had disappeared from the charts.
Phair quietly retreated from the spotlight during 1995, marrying Jim Staskausas, a Chicago-based film editor who had previously worked on
Phair's videos. Later in the summer of 1995, she released the
Juvenilia EP, which was essentially the "Jealousy" single amplified with the first official release of
Girlysound material. During the summer of 1996, she released "Rocket Boy," a single pulled from the Stealing Beauty soundtrack that received little attention. For much of 1996,
Phair worked on her third album with producer
Scott Litt, yet by the fall, she decided to scrap the sessions, unsatisfied with their sound. Toward the end of 1996, Staskausas and
Phair announced she was several months pregnant. On December 21, 1996, Phair gave birth to her first child, James Nicholas Staskausas. Her long-delayed, much-anticipated third LP,
whitechocolatespaceegg, finally appeared in mid-1998. Five years later,
Phair returned with a self-titled effort.
Liz Phair, which appeared in June 2003, found singer/songwriter
Michael Penn and
the Matrix in the production seat as well as
Phair herself.
Jimmy Chamberlin,
Wendy Melvoin, and
Pete Yorn also contributed to
Phair's newly slick sound. When
Liz Phair finally appeared in June 2003, it was panned by purist rock critics and militant Liz nerds who felt she'd sold them out with the record's pop star sensibilities. But Phair stood up for her work in typcally brash fashion - sometimes it seemed like she even invited the fan boy ridicule - and the album was a decent hit for her behind its single "Why Can't I", peaking at #27 on the Billboard 200. The quieter Somebody's Miracle appeared in fall 2005. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine, All Music Guide