Torch Songs may not do vocal-jazz fans too many favors, but it's an intriguing collection for those who want to hear a broad-based set of downbeat (and down-hearted) songs. Though jazz fans wouldn't dare compile songs by
Linda Ronstadt,
Carly Simon,
k.d. lang,
Patsy Cline, or
Diana Ross -- especially when the latter is covering
Billie Holiday; she also played
Holiday onscreen in
Lady Sings the Blues -- they're all represented with sympathetic material that sounds perfect in context. Most of the inclusions are the ones
any torch-song compilation has to have to be termed definitive -- "Cry Me a River" by
Julie London, "Stormy Weather" by
Lena Horne, "Black Coffee" by
Peggy Lee, "What a Diff'rence a Day Makes" by
Dinah Washington, and "La Vie en Rose" by
Edith Piaf. A pair of vocal giants,
Ella Fitzgerald ("But Not for Me") and
Billie Holiday ("Am I Blue?"), are treated by songs that are excellent if not defining. Similar to other Time-Life collections,
Torch Songs is the type that the beginner will love but the committed fan might find unnecessary. ~ John Bush, All Music Guide