This is a strangely persuasive compilation. It's rare that "best of" packages have songs from a variety of labels, yet maybe the fact that this is a German release had something to do with this draw.
You Really Got Me: The Very Best of the Kinks essentially consists of three-fourths Pye/Reprise material (i.e. the '60s) and another one-fourth of Arista and MCA work (i.e. the "dark" years). What's even more rare is that this import collection is quite good. Because instead of re-compiling the exact same singles for the hundredth time, there is a strange -- yet engaging -- idea of throwing in relatively underexposed selections ("Come on Now") right against the expected standards ("All Day and All of the Night"). This slightly schizophrenic tactic works in the album's favor. Even when one wonders why they chose to stick on such well-intentioned
Kinks debacles as "Don't Forget to Dance" or "Mr. Pleasant" yet ignore such undisputed classics as "A Well Respected Man" or "Too Much on My Mind." The second disc, however, has the most problems as its strict narrative peculiarity starts to frustrate instead of charm. In lieu of a natural, smooth progression throughout the years, it starts to bounce around all sorts of tracks from various stages of the band's career. For instance, while the listener is listening to 1966's "I'm Not Like Everybody Else," the compilation will leap to 1986's "Think Visual" (even someone in love with their "shuffle" function would start to lose patience). The added oversight of any real sleeve notes to speak of -- in German or anything else -- might also put off even obsessive collectors. To be fair, though, the vast majority of picks here are still often masterpieces no matter where they are placed on the album. It's hard to deny that amidst the gargantuan avalanches of
Kinks reissues and "greatest hits" packages,
You Really Got Me: The Very Best of the Kinks marks one of the most affordable, interesting compilations ever cobbled together for the band. ~ Dean Carlson, All Music Guide