Departed turned out to be where
the Cranberries' best intentions finally and thoroughly tripped them up. Switching producers to
Bruce Fairbairn was a troubling enough move to begin with;
Stephen Street's ear for the band's dynamics was note-perfect, but
Fairbairn's work with arena-rock monsters like
Aerosmith meant on
Departed everything was scaled up accordingly. The results may have been more commercial, but they took the identity of the band with it -- that opening song "Hollywood" sounded exactly like atypical sludgefest "Zombie" was all to be expected.
O'Riordan, meanwhile, decided she was a generation's spokesperson, fully taking over the songwriting, except on a couple of cuts with
Noel Hogan, penning some appropriate liner notes, and running with it. Songtitles say it all -- "War Child," "I Just Shot John Lennon," complete with cheesy gun shots, and perhaps most painfully obvious at the end, "Bosnia." Then there's lead single "Salvation," which preaches against heroin addiction in a manner worthy of afterschool specials and with about as much depth. Not that good songs can't and haven't been written on these subjects, of course, but
O'Riordan, lacking a truly individual or unique take on them, is not the person to be writing them. Or singing them -- her wails and yelps now run rampant, being less voice-as-instrument as it is signature calling card to be employed throughout. There are bright points -- every so often
Hogan's guitar comes through at its best, and there's the retro-'50s finger-snapping "When You're Gone" and the nicely arranged "Electric Blue." Still, when compared to
No Need and especially
Everybody Departed completely suffers in comparison. ~ Ned Raggett, All Music Guide