Symphony X had already established a devoted following prior to the release of
The Divine Wings of Tragedy, but it was this release that propelled them to the forefront of progressive metal bands. While often compared to
Dream Theater and
Yngwie Malmsteen there is enough creative writing and playing to distinguish them from other imitators. Guitarist
Michael Romeo usually garnishes most of the praise for his pyrotechnic displays, but keyboardist
Michael Pinnella and bassist
Thomas Miller are equally competent on their respective instruments. There are many excellent moments here, but
Russell Allen's vocals can be a bit grating, often sounding too much like
Ronnie James Dio. The 20-minute-plus "The Divine Wings of Tragedy" is based upon
Gustav Holst's "Mars: The Bringer of War," which is a piece that lends itself perfectly to this style of music. While this recording may not be quite the classic that it is often heralded to be, it is a noteworthy addition to the annals of progressive metal. ~ Robert Taylor, All Music Guide