While the single-disc
Greatest Hits and the double-disc
Anthology function as ideal introductions to
Sly & the Family Stone, this triple-disc set goes a step further. The other two best-ofs supply just the hits; this collection includes the
Greatest Hits album but then gives you something that the other two didn't offer: the album experience.
There's a Riot Goin' On and
Fresh proved that
Sly & the Family Stone were more than just a singles group. Released in 1971 and 1973, respectively, these two fully realized albums featured a genuine cohesiveness from beginning to end, characterized by spiritual, introspective funk. You miss out on this unless you sit down and play these albums all the way through; the sum of their parts is far greater than the songs on their own. For example, "Family Affair" was a fantastic hit for
Sly, a wonderful moment of soul-exuding funk. But the song takes on a whole new meaning when heard as the summit of
There's a Riot Goin' On's murky disorientation. The same goes for "If You Want Me to Stay," a wonderful starting point for the successive songs on
Fresh. Furthermore, the inclusion of
Greatest Hits in this triple-disc collection is just as vital, providing most everything else from
Sly's career that is really worth bothering with in terms of singles. Granted, you can't go wrong with the single-disc
Greatest Hits or the double-disc
Anthology -- they're both amazing starting points for neophytes -- but they don't offer what this triple-disc set does: the album experience in addition to
Sly's best singles. It might just be worth the extra money, since the other best-ofs may still leave you hungry for both
There's a Riot Goin' On and
Fresh in their entirety. ~ Jason Birchmeier, All Music Guide