Iced Earth produces one of the most convincing live albums of the '90s.
Alive in Athens crushes with the same monumental energy as
Iron Maiden's
Live After Death and
Blind Guardian's
Tokyo Tales, quite a lofty feat. With a visual approach akin to the "Eddie marketing campaign" of
Maiden,
Iced Earth has thrust themselves into the proverbial power metal spotlight with a destructively catchy sound to back it up. Live,
Matt Barlow's soaring vocals pierce with studio-like quality, while the guitar pairing of
Jon Schaffer and
Larry Tarnowski echoes back to the glory days of a previously mentioned British supergroup. Not to be missed either is bassist
James Macdonough, who, while not flashy, certainly is the glue of the band's tighter-than-thou power metal sound.
Iced Earth staples like "Dark Saga," "Stormrider," "Last December," and "Pure Evil" are included, along with newer cuts from their last album,
Something Wicked This Way Comes.
Iced Earth is quite adept at wielding the energy of the crowd (similar to
Blind Guardian) to their advantage. They use it to give the live sound a burst of energy that entraps the listener, leaving them at the band's mercy. [This version of the album includes an additional CD of bonus material.] ~ Jason Hundey, All Music Guide