An expanded three-disc collection that attempts to trump a 1994 double-disc set (
Amazing Grace: His Greatest Sacred Songs) by offering virtually every single
Elvis recording of a sacred song, Peace in the Valley: The Complete Gospel Recordings accomplishes the mission in its title, but at a hefty price that won't appeal to any but the most obsessive-compulsive fan. Obviously, it includes each track from his three gospel LPs -- 1960's
His Hand in Mine, 1967's
How Great Thou Art, and 1972's
He Touched Me -- plus scattered alternate takes that are previously unreleased. The third disc is padded out with an array of
Elvis' sacred recordings that are easily available elsewhere, like the 13 gospel tracks on the raw
Million Dollar Quartet session recorded at Sun in 1956, the "Gospel Medley" from his 1968 TV Special, and a version of "(There'll Be) Peace in the Valley" originally aired on
Ed Sullivan's television show. Though there's no doubt that Peace in the Valley: The Complete Gospel Recordings is a complete set, most
Elvis fans will gain little from owning it. ~ John Bush, All Music Guide